Cafe & Deli Menu Online Rosh Hahana Ordering Cafe & Deli Menu… Not too sure how the presence of the outside of an establishment dictates expectations for a great sandwich like someone else posted, but the place is absolutely worth a stop. As a recommendation from Jesse (Lakeside Resort), he told us the best subs are at the Holy Cow Meat shop. Salads were good also. Best. They were good but nothing special. Won't return here. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. We stopped here to get something for a picnic when we went on a ride. Won't return here.More. We plan to return and try other...sandwich!More. Had high expectations but the place was just average. more, Rooster Fish Brewing Tasting Room & Beer Garden. Seafood fresh, great bone in pork chops, special ordered pork belly was fresh and excellent quality. Holy Cow Menus. Both large and very good. Please check with the restaurant directly. High priced sub (had a large), nothing special to commend it, and not much food for the price. Prime all the way, outstanding. Lots of parking next to shop. We visited Watkins Glen in June of 2019 to do some hiking in the park. Holy Cow Meat Market & Deli « Back To Watkins Glen, NY. Definitely would suggest this place! Got tomahawk ribeyes. We'll stick with Jerlando's or Glen Mt Market next time. The meat was plentiful and the roll was so soft! Awesome sandwiches!! Pay adequate prices for eating at Holy Cow. Online Rosh Hahana Ordering Online Rosh Hahana Ordering Online Rosh Hahana Ordering. 398 E 4th St # 300, Watkins Glen, New York, USA, 14891-1215, Great little sandwich shop. Just the perfect lunch! Superb sandwich - we shared a large Godfather. The ladies behind the counter were sweet and recommended the daily special of chicken noodle soup which my husband loved. We had chicken salad and roast beef sandwiches and potato salad to go. We’d be back!More. Invite your family with you to enjoy mouthwatering sandwiches, pasta salads and chicken. Due to Covid-19, restaurant open hours and service may differ. The food is very reasonably priced, and the staff was helpful and extremely friendly. We liked the looks of the place and couldn’t help notice that they were busy. Not too sure how the presence of the outside of an establishment dictates expectations for a great sandwich like someone else posted, but the place is absolutely worth a stop. Much better alternatives elsewhere. Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate? Closed. We’d be back! We had chicken salad and roast beef sandwiches and potato salad to go. Ever! We decided to try this little deli shop one day after passing it so many times. The meats are all superb. Is this a place where you pay before receiving your order? Similar to other customer complaint. They we all outstanding! 0.26 mi. Hotels with Complimentary Breakfast in Watkins Glen, Hotels near International Motor Racing Research Center, Hotels near Watkins Glen Area Chamber of Commerce, Hotels near (ITH) Tompkins County Airport, Hotels near (ELM) Elmira Regional Airport, American Restaurants for Families in Watkins Glen, American Restaurants for Lunch in Watkins Glen, Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Watkins Glen. The food is very reasonably priced, and the staff was helpful and extremely friendly. As stated, don’t miss the Holy Cow Deli if you’re staying in Watkins Glen. View the online menu of Holy Cow Meat Market & Deli and other restaurants in Watkins Glen, New York. We had a meatball sub and a Rubin. We are from Long Island and complete snobs when it comes to eating sandwiches outside the Island because we have some of the best delis. Decision. Great service, nice folks. Only reason it didn't get 5 stars is because I personally didn't care for the bread. My husband and I stopped in here after a nice walk at the Glen. For $8.50 we were very disappointed. The roll was the cheap puffy kind not chewy like a sub roll should be. Split a large sub and grab a bag of chips!! The ladies behind the counter were sweet and recommended the daily special of chicken noodle soup which my husband loved. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Their Rachel was delicious! We popped in after our hike up the Glen. Rosh Hashana Menu Online Rosh Hahana Ordering Online Rosh Hahana Ordering. They we all outstanding! Much better subs with...much more generous portions of ingredients can be had at this price point. All I...can say is that if I lived in Watkins Glen, I would set up a tent outside of this deli, and after a few months I’d need to be moved in a wheel barrow! Rosh Hashana Menu. Great sandwiches, Cole slaw and pasta salad. All info on Holy Cow in Watkins Glen - Call to book a table. 398 E 4th St # 300, Watkins Glen, NY 14891-1215. Mostly cold cuts but they made a good sandwich. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. Get quick answers from Holy Cow Deli staff and past visitors. Split a large sub and grab a bag of chips!! the meat on the sandwich was just the right amount. much more generous portions of ingredients can be had at this price point. Is this a place where you buy ingredients to cook your own food? Enjoy. As stated, don’t miss the Holy Cow Deli if you’re staying in Watkins GlenMore, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Would highly recommend anyday! The place was in a large place (an old Pizza Hut from the looks of it) so we figured the sandwiches would be really great. The meats are all superb. View the menu, check prices, find on the map, see photos and ratings. I got their “uncle Quinny” sub and it was next level delicious! The bread was FRESH, soft, and...the meat on the sandwich was just the right amount. We found the Holy Cow Deli through TripAdvisor and stopped for a take out lunch (The marina, lake shore, and picnic tables are just a short walk away). Got 2 small subs, they were average at best. Holy Cow Deli, Watkins Glen: See 21 unbiased reviews of Holy Cow Deli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #27 of 38 restaurants in Watkins Glen. Masks required and they practice distancing. Humongous portions, excellent meats, super soft bun.